Skip to content
Money and Pensions Service Website
  • About us
    • Who we are
    • Board
      • Advisory Group to the Board
    • Executive Leadership Team
    • MoneyHelper
      • Share our cost of living campaign
    • Welsh Language Scheme
    • Careers
  • Our work
    • UK Strategy for Financial Wellbeing
      • What is financial wellbeing?
    • Talk Money Week
      • Talk Money Week for schools
    • Debt
      • Breathing Space
      • Money Adviser Network
      • Quality Assurance Framework
    • Pensions
    • Money Guiders
    • Talk Learn Do
  • Work with us
    • Build financial wellbeing in your location
      • Scotland
      • Northern Ireland
      • Wales
      • North West England
      • North East England
      • Yorkshire and the Humber
      • West Midlands
      • East Midlands
      • East of England
      • London
      • South West England
      • South East England
    • Employers
    • Financial services
    • Health and social care
    • Housing
    • Local authorities
    • Schools
    • Procurement
  • Media centre
    • Press office
    • Press releases
    • Financial wellbeing blog
  • Publications
    • Business plan and Corporate Strategy
    • Consultations and responses
    • Research
    • MoneyHelper pension take up dashboard

Cookies on maps.org.uk


Cookies are files saved on your phone, tablet or computer when you visit a website. We use cookies to store information about how you use MaPS, such as the pages you visit. For more information visit our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.

Some cookies are essential for the site to function correctly, such as those remembering your progress through our tools, or using our webchat service.

These cookies allow us to collect anonymised data about how our website is being used, helping us to make improvements to the services we provide to you.


Reject additional cookies Save preferences Accept all cookies

Findings from call for evidence on debt advice clients with deficit budgets

Published on:

30 August 2023

Deficit (or negative) budgets have been a feature of debt advice for several years. However, providers have reported significant growth in clients with deficit budgets lately.

Despite the debt advice sector’s familiarity with these clients, achieving good outcomes for them is not easy and this creates challenges not just for the clients themselves, but for advisers and the sector’s overall capacity.

Why we published a call for evidence

In light of the above, we published a call for evidence on deficit budgets in August 2022, with the aim of:

  1. Developing a greater knowledge of deficit budget clients, including the different client cohorts that exist and their respective needs.
  2. Learning how debt advice might support deficit budget clients to achieve better, longer-lasting outcomes, and what providers would need to deliver this (including from us).
  3. Understanding how advice providers and creditors could work together to deliver better outcomes for clients, based on a shared understanding of clients and their needs.

The call for evidence received 24 written responses from organisations and individuals. Insight was also received via discussions with other organisations. We would like to thank all these stakeholders for taking time to support us with this work.

Key findings

Responses identified a range of challenges and potential opportunities in relation to deficit budgets:

  • When clients often present in a state of hardship, advisers need to spend time helping with pressing needs before they can effectively engage clients with debt advice.
  • It is often not possible to effectively resolve issues, or even move advice forward, without tackling wider issues.
  • Some clients need more intensive support – with clients with additional vulnerabilities being particularly likely to have challenges engaging with the process.
  • Advice recommendations often require clients to undertake complex actions themselves, and clients may not be capable of this without assistance. In particular, clients may need support with income maximisation.
  • Creating a sustainable budget is challenging for deficit budget clients and significant time needs to be expended on this.
  • Where a client’s issues are complex, cases can remain open for long periods. For example, where a client’s benefit situation is under review (for example, because a benefit decision is being appealed) it can take time for income to be confirmed and this may involve significant collaboration and communication with government departments.
  • During this time, advisers may need to actively manage and attain support and forbearance from creditors, which can incur significant and ongoing resource.
  • Finally, for this cohort of clients there can be barriers to debt solution access, in particular barriers to insolvency which make it difficult to move forward.

Respondents emphasized that there is no ‘magic bullet’ that will help all deficit budget clients – who often face challenges outside the power of debt advice to tackle. However, respondents also identified actions that could make a difference to many clients. The report explores these opportunities, as well as what the unmet needs of deficit budget clients may mean for advice models and how ‘success’ is defined and measured. It concludes with our plans for taking this work forward.

Call for evidence report 2023 (PDF/A, 821KB) Opens in a new window
Back to top
Debt Debt advice All consultations and responses

Also see

  • What is financial wellbeing?
  • UK Strategy for Financial Wellbeing
  • MoneyHelper

LEGAL

  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy notice
  • Cookie policy
  • Money and Pensions Service standards
  • Public information
  • Subject access requests
  • Accessibility statement
  • Cookie preference

OUR BRANDS

  • MoneyHelper Opens in a new window
  • Financial Capability Strategy for the UK Opens in a new window

STAY IN TOUCH

  • Contact us
  • Sign up to newsletter Opens in a new window
  • Twitter Opens in a new window
  • LinkedIn Opens in a new window
  • YouTube Opens in a new window

Copyright 2025 Money & Pensions Service, Borough Hall, Cauldwell Street, Bedford, MK42 9AB.

All rights reserved.